Case study 06
AI Opportunity Assessment & Business Case
An evaluation of AI-enabled capabilities, including opportunity assessment, value analysis, implementation considerations, and a recommended path forward.
- ScenarioA fictional finance operations team asked to "use AI"
- My roleProduct manager leading the assessment
- StakeholdersFinance leaders, data team, IT security, internal audit
- OutputOpportunity matrix, business case, pilot plan
The problem
Start with the work, not the model
Leadership asked the finance operations team to find ways to use AI. The risk with a request like that is picking the most impressive idea instead of the most valuable one.
I turned it into a different question: which repetitive, high-volume work can AI do well enough, with a human checking what it is not sure about, at a cost that pays back?
My approach
Value, feasibility, risk
- Collect candidatesListed tasks with high volume and clear rules from interviews with the finance team.
- Score business valueHours saved, cost of errors, and speed gained.
- Score complexityIs the data available and clean? How accurate must it be? Can a person review the uncertain cases?
- Place on the matrixHigh value and lower complexity first; high value and high complexity becomes the longer bet.
- Business case and pilotA business case for the top candidate and a pilot with clear go and stop rules.
Sample artifact
Business case: invoice classification
| Line | Value | How it is calculated |
|---|---|---|
| Invoices per month | 40,000 | Synthetic volume |
| Manual coding time | 2,000 h / month | 40,000 invoices x 3 minutes |
| Coded automatically | 70% | The rest goes to a person for review |
| Hours saved | 1,400 h / month | 2,000 h x 70% |
| Yearly savings | $672,000 | 1,400 h x $40 x 12 months |
| Yearly run cost | $120,000 | Licenses, hosting, monitoring |
| One-time build | $250,000 | Integration, training data, testing |
| Payback | about 5.5 months | $250,000 / ($672,000 - $120,000) x 12 |
Synthetic numbers. The case still holds at half the automation rate: payback in about 14 months.
Key decisions
The recommendation
Invoice classification first
High value, lower complexity, and the answer is easy to check.
Pilot in one business unit for 8 weeks. Go if at least 95% of automatically coded invoices are correct; stop or rework if not.
A person reviews what the model is unsure about
Options: full automation, or automation with review.
Review below a confidence threshold. It keeps accuracy high and gives the team training data to improve the model.
Anomaly detection next, forecasting later
Both are valuable but need cleaner data and more history.
Sequenced after the data foundation work. Automated reconciliation stays a quick win the team can do with rules, without AI.
Outcomes
How success is measured
- 95%Accuracy on invoices coded automatically
- 70%Invoices coded without manual work
- 1,400 hStaff hours freed each month
- 8 weeksPilot before any decision to scale
Illustrative targets. The approach is the point: start with the work, check feasibility honestly, and let a small pilot with clear rules decide what scales.
Illustrative example. This work sample uses a fictional scenario and synthetic data. It does not contain confidential or proprietary employer information.